Think You Understand Your Dog? Science Says… LOL, No.

We love our dogs so much we invented an entire internet made of them. Entire careers exist because our furry roommates tilt their heads or do one dramatic sigh. So you’d think, after millions of years of co-evolution, we humans would be experts at reading dog emotions.

Turns out we might be absolute amateurs.

According to a 2024 Arizona State University study published in Applied Animal Behaviour Science, humans are wildly overconfident in their dog-reading abilities, and worse, we’re often reacting to everything except the actual dog.

Yep. We’re out here guessing feelings based on vibes and vacuum cleaners.

The Wild Part: We’re Looking at the WRONG THING

“We humans think we can easily tell what our dog is feeling,” says lead researcher Holly Molinaro, who studies animal welfare at ASU. “Our research shows this is not the case. In fact, people aren’t even looking at the dog when they're trying to perceive their emotions.” (Source: BBC Science Focus, 2024)

Let me repeat that:
We are literally not looking at our dogs.

Instead, we’re staring at the context: the treat in someone’s hand, the vacuum, the leash. Then we assume the dog feels how we feel about those things.

The study’s co-author, ASU psychology professor Clive Wynne, put it perfectly:
“Our dogs are trying to communicate with us, but we humans seem determined to look at everything except the poor pooch himself.”

The Experiments That Exposed Our “Dog Whisperer” Delusions

The researchers filmed a dog reacting to different situations, some happy (getting the leash), some meh (mild scolding). Then:

Experiment 1

383 people watched the videos, once with context, once without.

Experiment 2

The researchers tricked viewers by mismatching the dog’s behavior with the wrong context, making a happy moment look sad, and vice versa.

The results were chaotic:

• When viewers saw the dog “reacting” to a vacuum, they said the dog felt sad and stressed.

• When the exact same dog behavior was shown but paired with a leash, viewers rated it happy and calm.

Same dog. Same reaction. Completely different human interpretations.
(Source: Molinaro & Wynne, 2024)

So yeah, love that for us.

Wait It Gets Worse: We Project Our Own Emotions Onto Them

People who were in a good mood were more likely to assume the dog was happy, regardless of the dog’s actual behavior.
(Source: Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2024)

Basically
If you’re stressed, your dog suddenly becomes “stressed.”
If you’re having a great day
Wow look at Mr. Happy Go Lucky over there wagging his tail (which he absolutely wasn’t).

So yes, you're not just misreading your dog, you’re creating emotional fan fiction.

“But I Know My Dog.”

Do you really?

The participants in the study were strangers to the dog. Fair. But when Molinaro showed the mismatched videos to her own dad, a man who acted in the videos with the dog, he still got the emotions wrong.

Buddy was literally in the scene. Still flopped.

This is the scientific equivalent of “no, really, it’s not just you.”

“So How Do We Get Better?”

Your Dog Deserves That Emotional MBA.

1. Be humble.

You’re probably not the dog-reading genius you think you are. Yes, even you, the parent who swears their dog “smiles.”

2. Watch the DOG, not the situation.

Tail, ears, vocalizations, body tension. These nonverbal cues matter more than the presence of a treat or the fact that a toddler dropped an entire pouch of blueberries on the floor.

3. Study your dog like it’s your favorite show.

Every dog has unique micro-expressions, quirks, and tells.
There is no universal dog emotion dictionary, only the one your dog is writing in real time.

4. Remember that context still matters but only when combined with behavior.

You wouldn’t read a human without considering mood, culture, personality, etc. Dogs deserve that same nuance.

5. Pay attention to the small stuff.

Behavioral nuance is where the truth lives. Is that wag slow? Fast? Low? Helicopter mode? These all mean different things.

The Takeaway

Dog emotions are subtle, and we humans are confidently clueless.
But with more mindfulness, better observation, and way less projection, you can actually learn your dog’s real emotional language.

This matters, like actually matters, because misreading cues can lead to:

• Stress and anxiety in dogs

• Missed signs of fear or pain

• Behavioral issues

• Lower quality of life

• Unsafe interactions with kids, strangers, and other dogs
  (Cited: American Veterinary Medical Association; Fear Free Pets; IAABC)

And if we love our dogs like family, and you absolutely do, then learning their emotional language isn't optional.

It’s part of the job.

Good news: your dog has been trying to tell you everything this whole time.

You just have to start listening.

“The Squeeze”: Dog News In 60 Seconds

• 🇳🇱 The Netherlands is the first country to eliminate stray dogs

• 🇨🇳 Dogs in China are going to see Zootopia 2

• ✈️ This is why I fly Delta

• 😞 Pet parents clamor for pet bereavement leave in the workplace

Today’s Last Laugh:

Mood

@scarlettderr

Corgi check-up 😊🐶 Follow us @corgi.pack for more adorable corgi moments! 🐶✨ . . . 📽️ Credit: To the original creator ©️柯代表可乐 If this is ... See more